Opinion: Jason Doesn’t Need a New Movie. Peacock Needs to Renew ‘Crystal Lake’ Now
Tomorrow is Friday the 13th, and for the first time in 17 years, Jason Voorhees actually has something new to celebrate. Peacock's Crystal Lake dropped all eight episodes on October 15, debuted at No. 1 in the U.S. and Canada, and became the first project in franchise history to earn a fresh score from critics on Rotten Tomatoes. Four weeks later, Peacock still hasn't renewed it. Meanwhile, co-creator Sean S. Cunningham keeps saying a new "old school" movie is in the works.
Here's our take, and we'll stand behind it: Friday the 13th doesn't need another movie right now. It needs Crystal Lake Season 2. The franchise spent four decades proving it can make money in theaters and almost nothing else. The show proved, in one season, that this story can be good. Below: the numbers, the track record, why TV fits Jason better than anyone expected, the fair case for the big screen, and what Peacock should do next.
Watch the Trailer
Peacock's official full trailer, released September 13:
And the first teaser from July, which is still the best 51 seconds of Linda Cardellini whispering to a lake you'll see this year:
1. The Movies Made Money. They Almost Never Made Fans Out of Critics.
Let's be fair to the films first, because the money is real. Twelve movies, from the 1980 original through the 2009 reboot, grossed about $468 million worldwide on a combined budget of roughly $81 million. Sean Cunningham's original cost about $550,000 and made nearly $60 million. Freddy vs. Jason is still the series' biggest hit at $116.6 million worldwide in 2003. Marcus Nispel's 2009 reboot opened on, yes, Friday, February 13 and pulled in $92.7 million on a $19 million budget.
Now look at what critics thought. CBR ran the Rotten Tomatoes table in October, and it's brutal: the 1980 original sits at 48 percent. Jason Lives , the fan favorite, has 39. Jason Takes Manhattan has 8. Not one film with Jason in it has ever landed a fresh score. Crystal Lake opened at 86 percent and has settled at 77 percent from 77 reviews, with a 61 on Metacritic and an audience score of 88. That's the franchise's best critical showing ever, and it isn't close.
You can argue Rotten Tomatoes doesn't matter for slashers, and plenty of us love Part VI no matter what the score says. But the point isn't that critics finally approved. The point is that the series finally found a format where the story gets room to breathe, and people noticed.
2. The Show Is Already a Hit, and the Numbers Say So
According to NBCUniversal figures reported by Collider and JoBlo, Crystal Lake racked up 1.3 billion minutes viewed in its first 11 days, making it Peacock's fourth-biggest scripted original debut ever. Nielsen had it at No. 3 among streaming original series for the week of October 19. The show also stayed at No. 1 for two straight weeks in Canada, where it streamed on Crave.
For a streamer that still lives in Netflix's shadow, that's a big deal. Peacock doesn't have dozens of original horror franchises sitting around. It has one with a hockey mask (well, eventually) and a name everybody knows. And as we covered earlier this month, Peacock already passed on Eli Roth's Hostel series with Paul Giamatti. If it's going to bet on horror, this is the bet already paying off.
3. Linda Cardellini Is the Argument
Betsy Palmer's Mrs. Voorhees is one of horror's great reveals, but in 1980 she got about 15 minutes of screen time to go from friendly camp cook to beheaded killer. The films never had time to ask what grief does to a person over years. A series does.
Nearly every review circled the same thing. THR's Daniel Fienberg called Cardellini the main reason to keep watching. IGN's Scott Collura said the show works largely because of her. Even Titus Welliver jumped on Instagram to call her "the gold standard." Showrunner Brad Caleb Kane told Collider that Cardellini was his first choice, and in interviews he keeps coming back to how much grief she carries on screen. The production even thought about copying Palmer's hairstyle before deciding it would feel like cosplay. That's a team that understood the assignment: honor the original, don't imitate it.
You can't get that performance in a 95-minute reboot. You get it in eight hours.
4. The Timeline Practically Demands More Seasons
This is the strongest point in favor of TV, and it comes from the show itself. Per JoBlo, Kane has said the events of the 1980 movie are still eight years away at the end of Season 1. That's a long runway, and it's the kind TV is built for. Kane has already told Bloody Disgusting (via CBR) that he wants "a whole hell of a lot more" of Sackhead Jason, more carnage, franchise characters who haven't shown up yet, and William Catlett's Chief Levon Brooks back as the lead. JoBlo reports Kane even floated a possible tie to the Jarvis family, which would make every Tommy Jarvis fan lose their mind.
Kane also told Collider the show recreates scenes from the movies in new contexts and uses Jason "liberally," and that's the trick. The films kept resetting Jason every few years, rebooting him, sending him to hell, sending him to space. The show can build him slowly from a kid who loves holding a machete (young star Callum Vinson's favorite killer is Art the Clown, per Kane) into the thing in the woods. Watching a monster get made is a better story than watching a monster get reset.
5. TV Is Where Horror's Old Franchises Have Been Thriving
There's a track record here. Bates Motel took a 1960 classic and ran five seasons on A&E by treating Norman's mother as a person, not a twist. Starz's Ash vs Evil Dead gave Bruce Campbell three seasons after the movies stalled. Don Mancini kept Chucky alive for three seasons when the theatrical lane dried up. And Kane himself came to this job from HBO's It: Welcome to Derry , another prequel that grew a movie mythology into a TV world.
Compare that to the theatrical side. Warner set an August 13, 2010 date for a sequel to the reboot, then pulled it that December. Writers Damian Shannon and Mark Swift finished a script by 2011. A Paramount reboot died in 2017. Then the Victor Miller rights fight froze everything for years. In May 2024, Cunningham said studios were hesitant to fund a horror movie that might not be a financial success. In March 2026, he told TMZ a treatment for an "old school" movie was done and that he and Miller had worked things out. There's still no greenlight, director, cast or date. The show isn't a placeholder for the movie. Right now it's the only part of this franchise that actually works.
Photo: Sean S. Cunningham via Wikimedia Commons ( author and license).
6. The Other Side: Jason Belongs in a Packed Theater
The case against us is real, so let's make it properly. Slashers are a crowd experience. Part of the joy of a Friday movie is a theater full of people groaning at the same kill. The genre's theatrical lane is alive, too: Terrifier 3 made about $90 million worldwide on a tiny budget, and David Gordon Green's Halloween made over $250 million in 2018. Damien Leone is heading back for Terrifier 4 , and A24 should be watching that like a hawk.
The reviews weren't all raves, either. The Guardian's Benjamin Lee called the expansion unnecessary and the tone uneven. TIME's Judy Berman argued the premise was never rich enough to stretch this far. IndieWire's Ben Travers wasn't wowed by where it lands. And plenty of fans just want a grown Jason in a hockey mask, which Season 1 doesn't give them. Kane Hodder, who played him four times, is still the face a lot of fans picture, and no prequel about Pamela's grief can replace that.
Photo: Kane Hodder by Gage Skidmore via Wikimedia Commons ( author and license).
We hear all of it. But "fans want the mask" is an argument for Season 2 and 3, not against them. The show is heading to the mask. A rushed movie that skips the journey would just be reboot number two, and history tells us how those end: one big opening and then another decade of nothing.
What Peacock Should Do
- Renew it now. Every week of silence lets the cast scatter. Cardellini, Catlett and Hamish Linklater are not going to sit around.
- Keep Kane. The project already burned through Bryan Fuller and Kevin Williamson before he steadied it. Don't start over again.
- Plan the endgame. Eight years of story left means a clear finish line: end the series where the 1980 film begins. That's a better pitch for a movie than anything sitting in a drawer.
- Let the movie wait. If Cunningham's "old school" film happens, it'll be stronger walking in behind a hit show than replacing one.
Bottom Line
For 17 years, Friday the 13th was a famous name with nowhere to go. Crystal Lake gave it somewhere: a slower, sadder, still bloody story about the woman who made the monster, with the best reviews the series has ever had and the viewership to back them up. A theatrical Jason can come later. Right now, the smartest move this franchise can make is to stay at camp.
So tell us, on the eve of Friday the 13th: would you rather get Crystal Lake Season 2 or a brand-new Jason movie first? Make your case in the comments. We know some of you are already sharpening machetes.
Related on The Horror Feed
Header photo: Linda Cardellini at South by Southwest 2019 via Wikimedia Commons ( author and license), cropped with text added. Videos: Peacock official YouTube channel.
_(cropped).jpg){kind=link}
Recent STories
